Research, not advice. This is what I found in public sources about prop trading firms. It is not financial advice or a recommendation to buy any challenge. A challenge is a paid evaluation: most people who try one do not get funded, and the fee is usually not returned. Rules, prices and ratings change often, so confirm everything on the firm’s official site. Some links here are affiliate links, explained in the affiliate disclosure. See the full disclaimer.
Topstep, Tradeify and Apex Trader Funding are the three names beginners see first when they look for a futures prop firm. They sell paid evaluations on CME futures (E-mini S&P, Nasdaq, gold, crude), they pay a share of profits, and they differ on cost, drawdown and payout caps. These are my notes from public reviews and roundups, so use the figures as a starting point and confirm each one on the firm’s site.
Quick comparison
| # | Firm | Market | Founded | Public rating (reported) | Profit split | My score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Topstep | Futures | 2012 | reported 3.4–4.6 varies | 90/10 on Express funded accounts | 4.1 |
| 3 | Tradeify | Futures | c. 2024 | 4.3–4.7 sources conflict | 90/10 on simulated funded accounts | 3.7 |
| 6 | Apex Trader Funding | Futures | 2021 | ≈4.4 18,000+ | varies by plan; check official site | 3.3 |
Ratings are the figures reported in 2026 roundups unless a “checked” date is shown on the firm’s review. Scroll sideways on a phone.
| Topstep | Tradeify | Apex | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Founded | 2012 | c. 2024 | 2021 |
| Evaluation price (2026 roundups) | from about $109/month | about $139–$759 | about $137–$677/month (Rithmic) |
| Activation fee | none listed by one source | none reported | one-time, after passing |
| Drawdown | sources disagree | end-of-day trailing | EOD or intraday (your choice) |
| Reset price | check site | $85–$189 (Growth), $95 (Select), per one guide | check site |
| Reported split | 90/10 (Express) | 90/10 | varies by plan |
The prices come from third-party guides that are partly affiliate-supported and that disagree with each other, so I have not merged them into a single number. Promotions frequently cut the headline price, and the amount at checkout is the only figure that counts.
Topstep
TSee my Topstep review. Topstep has the longest history (2012, Chicago), a large community and a published payout policy. Complaints concern payout caps (reported in the low thousands per request on a 50K account), reported 2026 changes, and mixed star ratings depending on the roundup. It suits disciplined traders who value longevity and accept a trailing loss limit.
Tradeify
TSee my Tradeify review. Tradeify is newer, with several ways to pass an evaluation (including a soft daily loss limit on Growth) and reported fast payout processing. The central criticism is the gap between profit you must earn and profit you may withdraw per cycle, so model the caps before you buy. Its reset prices are among the clearest in the group.
Apex Trader Funding
ASee my Apex review. Apex relaunched as 4.0, which reviewers say removed subscriptions and resets in their old form and introduced EOD and intraday drawdown choices with one-time pricing. A one-time activation fee applies after passing, and one reviewer lists a 50% consistency rule on the performance account. Because the rules are new, there is less evidence of full payout cycles, and older articles can describe a model that no longer exists.
Which one I would study first as a beginner
- You want the longest record and a clear path: start with Topstep.
- You want flexibility and clear reset pricing: start with Tradeify.
- You want the lowest sticker price and can read a new rulebook carefully: look at Apex, and compare the total including activation.
Whichever you choose, work out the all-in cost: evaluation + activation + the number of resets you realistically expect, then compare it with the payout caps. Futures trading is leveraged and most people lose money; I make no claim that you will pass or be paid.
Mistakes beginners make with futures evaluations
- Choosing the biggest account because the profit target in dollars looks larger.
- Ignoring that a trailing drawdown moves up when you are winning.
- Trading the first week at full size without a written risk plan.
- Buying on a promotion without reading the consistency and payout rules.
Related reading
See the full Top 10 futures prop firms, the real cost of cheap evaluations and which prop firm I would start with.
Reminder: I do not claim that any firm here is safe, that you will pass a challenge, get funded or be paid, or that trading will be profitable. Ratings are my editorial judgement from public sources, which are often affiliate-funded and sometimes disagree. Commissions never change a score. Only pay what you can afford to lose.